Pros and cons · Renew Bariatrics
Gastric sleeve and gastric bypass are the two most common weight loss surgeries. Both lead to major weight loss, but they differ in how they work, how much weight you lose, their effect on health conditions, side effects, risks and cost. Here’s how they compare.
Renew offers both. Our surgeons will recommend one after reviewing your health history.
Free, no-obligation review
A coordinator will contact you about your options and quote, with no commitment.
Prefer to talk? Call (844) 736-3963, available 24/7.
Prefer to talk? Call 24/7 (844) 736-3963
Quick pros and cons
Both are done laparoscopically at Renew, through small incisions. The best choice depends on your BMI, reflux, health conditions and goals.
One stomach operation, with no rerouting of the intestine.
About 7 to 8 percentage points more excess weight lost at 5 and 10 years in two randomized trials (SM-BOSS, SLEEVEPASS).
1.0% needed another operation within 30 days, vs 2.5% after bypass (MBSAQIP).
Reflux damage at 10 years in 7% after bypass vs 31% after the sleeve (SLEEVEPASS).
$4,899 at Renew, vs $6,299 for gastric bypass.
Higher remission of high blood pressure at 10 years (SLEEVEPASS). Diabetes results were close.
How they work
Weight loss surgeries work by limiting how much you eat (restrictive), how much you absorb (malabsorptive), or both. The gastric sleeve is restrictive. Gastric bypass is restrictive and malabsorptive. Both also change the gut hormones that control hunger.


Side by side
| Gastric sleeveRestrictive | Gastric bypassRestrictive and malabsorptive | |
|---|---|---|
| Method of weight loss | Restrictive. A smaller stomach holds less food | Restrictive and malabsorptive. A small pouch, and part of the intestine is bypassed |
| Operating time | 68 minutes (median) | 113 minutes (median) |
| Your stay at Renew | 2 hospital nights, 1 hotel night | 2 hospital nights, 1 hotel night |
| BMI range at Renew | 29.5 to 65 | 29.5 to 55 |
| Weight loss at 1 year | 25% to 30% of body weight | About 31% of body weight |
| Weight loss at 5 years | 19% to 27% of body weight | 26% to 29% of body weight |
| Excess weight lost at 10 years | 43.5% (median) | 50.7% (median) |
| Another operation within 30 days | 1.0% | 2.5% |
| Reflux damage at 10 years | 31% | 7% |
| Vitamins | Daily vitamins and follow-up for life | Lifelong vitamins, including B12, iron and calcium, with regular lab checks |
| Recovery | 2 to 4 weeks | 2 to 4 weeks |
| Cost with Renew Bariatrics | $4,899, all-inclusive | $6,299, all-inclusive |
| US self-pay cost | About $18,000 on average | $19,000 to $28,000 |
Operating times from an MBSAQIP matched analysis, Surgical Endoscopy, 2023. Weight loss at 1 and 5 years from the PCORnet Bariatric Study, Annals of Internal Medicine, 2018, Kollmann et al., BJS Open, 2026 and Franken et al., Obesity Surgery, 2026. 10-year results from the SLEEVEPASS 10-year trial, JAMA Surgery, 2022. 30-day results from MBSAQIP 30-day outcomes, 2018. These are averages from studies. Your results will be different.
Results
Gastric bypass leads to somewhat more weight loss, and the gap lasts. Two randomized trials followed sleeve and bypass patients side by side for 5 and 10 years.
Health conditions
Both surgeries improve or resolve conditions such as type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, high cholesterol and sleep apnea. Gastric bypass did better for blood pressure, cholesterol and reflux. For type 2 diabetes, the difference between the two wasn’t significant in either trial.
| Gastric sleeve | Gastric bypass | |
|---|---|---|
| Type 2 diabetes in remission at 5 years | 61.5% | 67.9% |
| Type 2 diabetes in remission at 10 years | 26% | 33% |
| Off blood pressure medication at 10 years | 8% | 24% |
| High cholesterol in remission at 5 years | 42.6% | 62.3% |
| Off CPAP for sleep apnea at 10 years | 16% | 31% |
| Reflux resolved at 5 years, in people who had it | 25.0% | 60.4% |
| New reflux at 5 years, in people who didn’t have it | 31.6% | 10.7% |
5-year results from the SM-BOSS 5-year trial, JAMA, 2018. 10-year results from the SLEEVEPASS 10-year trial, JAMA Surgery, 2022. Each row includes only the patients who had that condition before surgery, so some groups are small.
Complications
Bleeding and leaks can happen after either surgery. Dumping syndrome, narrowing at the connection, ulcers and internal hernias are mainly seen after gastric bypass. Reflux (heartburn) is more common after the sleeve, so people with reflux before surgery are often advised to have a bypass. Nutritional deficiencies can happen after both, and are more likely after bypass (ASMBS nutrition guidelines).
Which is right for you?
You have a BMI of 29.5 to 65 and little or no reflux.
You want a simpler surgery, with no intestinal rerouting and a lower price.
You want the option to convert to another surgery later if needed.
You have reflux (GERD), which the sleeve can make worse.
You have a BMI of 29.5 to 55 and want more weight loss.
You’re ready for lifelong vitamins and regular lab checks.
Already had a sleeve? It can be converted to gastric bypass. You can also compare the mini gastric bypass or all 11 procedures we offer.
Cost
In the US, gastric bypass usually costs more than the sleeve. At Renew, the gastric sleeve is $4,899 and gastric bypass is $6,299, both all-inclusive except airfare. HSA and FSA are accepted, with financing available.
Send your health history and our surgeons will review your options. Virtual consultations are available.
5-star Google reviews. Want to talk with a past patient? Ask your coordinator.
“This experience has been an amazing one from the moment I got picked up till I got to the hospital the nurses are very well trained and made me feel at ease. I had a gastric sleeve on April 12th I was nervous but they made me feel welcome. The staff is amazing very well train the doctors were extremely attentive. The hospital is clean and welcoming. Dr. Perez is the best doctor I have ever come in counter with.”
“Staff, nurses, and Doctor Green were amazing. The facility did not disappoint. I had a bypass instead of the sleeve and I have no pain. This surgery has been excellent.”
“having gastric sleeve surgery with renew bariatrics was one of the most important decisions I have ever made! I have lost a significant amount of weight, but I have gained a lot of confidence and hope for the future! the whole staff has been excellent. the trip was very safe and coordinated and i was very nervous before going.”
“I had a gastric sleeve with Dr. Green. All the nurses are amazing especially Fernanda that went above and beyond, and made sure I was really good all night.”
from 850+ reviews across 4 platforms
Ratings and review counts as listed on each platform. Select a platform to read reviews there.
Neither is better for everyone. The sleeve is a simpler surgery with fewer early complications and a lower price. Gastric bypass leads to somewhat more weight loss and is usually better if you have reflux. Our surgeons will recommend one after reviewing your health history.
Gastric bypass. In the 10-year SLEEVEPASS trial, patients lost a median of 50.7% of their excess weight after bypass vs 43.5% after the sleeve.
Slightly, in the short term. In US data, 2.5% of bypass patients needed another operation within 30 days, vs 1.0% after the sleeve. Over 10 years, reoperation rates were similar: 18.5% after bypass and 15.7% after the sleeve.
Gastric bypass. The sleeve can cause new reflux or make it worse. At 10 years, 64% of sleeve patients took reflux medication vs 36% after bypass.
Both help. In two randomized trials, diabetes remission was a little higher after bypass, but the difference wasn’t significant.
Yes. A sleeve can be converted to gastric bypass or mini gastric bypass, most often for reflux or weight regain. It’s a custom quote at Renew.
The gastric sleeve is $4,899 and gastric bypass is $6,299, both all-inclusive except airfare. HSA and FSA are accepted, with financing available.
Free surgeon review
Tell us a little about you, and our team will follow up with your options and quote. No commitment.
Double board-certified surgeons with 9,000+ surgeries.
Prefer to talk? Call 24/7 (844) 736-3963
Free, no-obligation review
Form loading. Prefer to talk? Call (844) 736-3963, available 24/7.
No commitment. A coordinator will contact you.