Diet Failure Statistics: How Often Diets Fail?

Diet Failure

Surprisingly, 95% of these diets end up failing. One major hitch is that extreme diets often lead to short-term success, followed by a rebound effect. People end up regaining lost weight and then some.

Additionally, unrealistic expectations contribute to diet failures. Understanding these pitfalls is crucial for achieving lasting weight loss.

Key Diet Failure Statistics

  • After just one year, 35% of individuals find themselves back where they started, or even 5 pounds heavier. Despite initial efforts, the journey becomes more challenging over time.
  • A mere 6% manage to consistently shed pounds, while 59% successfully maintain their weight. It highlights the difficulty in achieving lasting weight loss.
  • Over half the weight lost in diets makes a comeback within two years.
  • More than two years post-diet, around 83% gain more than they lost.
  • One study reveals that after 5 years, half of dieters are carrying an extra 11 pounds. 
  • In under two years, 23% end up heavier than their starting point.
  • Holding onto weight loss for two years slashes the odds of gaining it back by 50%.
  • The average diet journey for women tends to last a mere 4 weeks, while men extend theirs slightly to 6 weeks.
  • Shedding a kilogram (2.2 lbs) may seem victorious, but it comes at a cost. The body’s calorie expenditure drops by 20 kcal/day, while appetite surges by 100 kcal/day.
  • Diets that impose bans on specific foods witness a surprising 133% surge in overeating of those very items, defeating the purpose.
  • Diets induce a rollercoaster of caloric intake, fluctuating by 20-30%. This mixed messaging confuses the brain about hunger signals.
  • Consuming just an extra 100 calories post-diet can lead to significant weight rebound, a trap many unsuspecting dieters fall into.
  • Without follow-up visits to healthcare professionals, dieters reclaim over 5% of their lost weight within 5 to 15 months.
  • A staggering 95% of individuals who eliminate specific food categories (like carbs or opting for liquid-only diets) find themselves reverting to their original weight.
  • A considerable 24% of people attempt weight loss one or two times, 28% make three to ten attempts, and 11% persist after more than ten trials.
  • Alarmingly, 10% of people venture into dieting without incorporating any exercise or structured program into their regimen.
  • Dieting Consistency

    A study in The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition found that individuals sticking to their diet throughout the week are 1.5 times more likely to keep the weight off.

    Here’s the scoop on diet habits:

  • Many dieters keep their game strong during the week but cut themselves some slack on weekends and holidays.
  • Surprisingly, 59% of dieters maintain the same eating routine on both weekdays and weekends.
  • When the festive season hits, 52% of dieters find it tougher to stick to their plans.
  • 45% admit to eating the same on holidays and vacations as they do during the rest of the year.
  • 39% tighten their dietary belts on weekdays, saving indulgence for the weekends.
  • Only 3% buckle down harder during holidays than regular days.
  • A mere 2% become stricter with their diet on weekends compared to weekdays.
  • Diet Trends 

    Understanding modern diet trends is crucial in navigating the maze of nutritional choices. Whether flying solo or pairing with various disciplines, how people approach diets can impact success.

    The most popular diet trends are:

  • Food Restrictions (87.6%): The top dog in dieting. People trying to shed pounds often opt for cutting out specific foods.
  • Quantity Quandary (44%): Many believe less is more. Almost half the dieters focus on controlling portions.
  • Calorie Countdown (43%): A significant chunk tracks their calorie intake. Among them, 25% zoom in on fat, 20% do math with a formula, and 22% hop on the ‘exchange program’ train, like Weight Watchers.
  • Dieting and Eating Disorders

    On average, 35% of people who start dieting end up taking it to the extreme, turning it into a serious problem. Shockingly, 20% to 25% of these individuals even develop eating disorders. Despite our efforts, the statistics show that a significant number of “normal dieters” end up crossing the line into what experts call “pathological dieting.” This term might sound daunting, but it simply means taking dieting to an unhealthy extreme.

    FAQs on Diet Failure

    Why do most diets fail?

    The majority of diets fail because they often lack essential nutrients, leading to nutritional imbalances. Restrictive eating can also cause gut intolerances due to a lack of food variety.

    Do diets actually work for long-term weight loss?

    Diets are not effective for sustained weight loss. They create a controlling relationship with food and may worsen weight problems. Opt for an intuitive eating approach for better results.

    What are 4 reasons diets don’t work?

  • Disordered Eating: Diets can lead to disordered eating patterns and a negative relationship with food.
  • Weight Gain: Contrary to the goal, diets are associated with weight gain, not loss.
  • Dieting Cycle: People often get stuck in a never-ending “dieting cycle.”
  • Limited Focus: Diets solely concentrate on food, neglecting overall health.
  • What diets should be avoided?

    Steer clear of overly-restrictive diets like Raw Food Diet, keto, Atkins, OPTAVIA, and SlimFast. These diets lack flexibility and may lead to nutritional imbalances, hindering long-term success.


  • Related Articles


    Related Articles