Pros and cons · Renew Bariatrics
The gastric sleeve and the duodenal switch are both weight loss surgeries, but the duodenal switch goes further. It starts with a sleeve and then reroutes the small intestine. At Renew, the duodenal switch is done as SADI-S, the single-connection version. Here’s how the two compare on weight loss, health conditions, risks and cost.
Renew offers both. SADI-S is performed by Dr. Héctor Pérez in Tijuana and Cancún.
Free, no-obligation review
A coordinator will contact you about your options and quote, with no commitment.
Prefer to talk? Call (844) 736-3963, available 24/7.
Prefer to talk? Call 24/7 (844) 736-3963
Quick pros and cons
Both are done laparoscopically, through small incisions. The best choice depends on your BMI, health conditions and how ready you are for lifelong vitamins.
One stomach operation, with no rerouting of the intestine.
19.5 BMI points lost at 2 years, vs 11.3 after the sleeve, at one US center (Enochs et al.).
SADI-S had more complications in the first 30 days in US registry data (MBSAQIP).
Fewer patients had a high HbA1c 12 months after SADI-S than after the sleeve (Enochs et al.).
SADI-S reduces how much you absorb, so lifelong vitamins and lab checks are essential (ASMBS).
$4,899 at Renew, vs $6,899 for SADI-S.
How they work
The gastric sleeve is restrictive: a smaller stomach holds less food. SADI-S is restrictive and malabsorptive: it starts with a sleeve, then bypasses part of the small intestine so you absorb fewer calories. The stomach valve (pylorus) is kept. Renew performs SADI-S, not the traditional duodenal switch (BPD-DS), which has two connections.


Side by side
| Gastric sleeveRestrictive | SADI-SRestrictive and malabsorptive | |
|---|---|---|
| Method of weight loss | A smaller stomach holds less food | A sleeve, plus part of the small intestine is bypassed |
| Surgeon at Renew | Our bariatric surgeons | Dr. Héctor Pérez, in Tijuana and Cancún |
| Your stay at Renew | 2 hospital nights, 1 hotel night | 2 hospital nights, 1 hotel night |
| BMI range at Renew | 29.5 to 65 | 40 to 65 |
| BMI points lost at 2 years | 11.3 | 19.5 |
| Weight loss at 5 years | 18.8% of body weight | 33.7% of body weight |
| Complications in the first 30 days | Lower | Higher |
| Bowel changes | Not expected | More frequent, looser stools are possible |
| Vitamins | Daily vitamins and follow-up for life | Lifelong vitamins, including A, D, E and K, with regular lab checks |
| Recovery | 2 to 4 weeks | 2 to 4 weeks |
| Cost with Renew Bariatrics | $4,899, all-inclusive | $6,899, all-inclusive |
| US self-pay cost | About $18,000 on average | $25,000 to $35,000 |
BMI points from Enochs et al., SOARD, 2020, which compared both surgeries at one center. Weight loss at 5 years comes from two different sources: the PCORnet Bariatric Study, Annals of Internal Medicine, 2018 for the sleeve and a review of 5-year SADI-S studies, Obesity Surgery, 2025 for SADI-S, so compare them with care. 30-day results from Clapp et al., MBSAQIP, SOARD, 2023. Bowel changes from Cleveland Clinic. These are averages from studies. Your results will be different.
Results
SADI-S leads to more weight loss than the sleeve, and the gap is largest in people with a higher BMI. In the one study that compared them at the same center, weight loss was greatest after SADI-S in every BMI group.
Health conditions
Both surgeries improve type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure and sleep apnea. SADI-S has a stronger effect on blood sugar. In the single-center study, fewer SADI-S patients had a high HbA1c at 12 months than sleeve patients (Enochs et al., SOARD, 2020). In the SM-BOSS trial, 61.5% of sleeve patients with diabetes were in remission at 5 years (SM-BOSS 5-year trial, JAMA, 2018). Because SADI-S starts with a sleeve, reflux can develop after either surgery.
Complications
Bleeding, leaks and reflux can happen after either surgery. SADI-S adds an intestinal connection, so it can also cause looser stools and a higher risk of protein, vitamin and mineral deficiencies. Lifelong supplements and lab checks are essential after SADI-S (ASMBS nutrition guidelines).
Which is right for you?
You have a BMI of 29.5 to 65 and want a simpler surgery.
You’d rather avoid changes to your intestine and bowel habits.
You want the option to convert to another surgery later if needed.
You have a BMI of 40 to 65 and want the most weight loss.
You have type 2 diabetes that’s hard to control.
You’re ready for lifelong vitamins and regular lab checks.
SADI-S can also be done later, after a sleeve, if weight loss stalls (primary and secondary SADI-S, 5-year outcomes). Ask about gastric sleeve revision, or compare the sleeve and gastric bypass.
Cost
At Renew, the gastric sleeve is $4,899 and SADI-S is $6,899, both all-inclusive except airfare. HSA and FSA are accepted, with financing available.
Send your health history and our surgeons will review your options. Virtual consultations are available.
5-star Google reviews. Want to talk with a past patient? Ask your coordinator.
“Renew is really great at focusing on your needs and will do everything they can to make you as comfortable as possible. They have many nurses around to help multiple patients at once. I was in the Tijuana location from 6/20-6/22 and had the gastric sleeve done. My surgery went well. I was especially nervous since it was my first surgery but they helped me to know exactly what was going on and answered all my questions! I’m very grateful I went through Renew for this life changing surgery!”
“I just had my procedure in Tijuana of the gastric sleeve! The staff is wonderful to work with and make you feel so safe and cared for!”
“I chose Dr. Perez based on recommendations from a few friends that have previously used him. He is amazing. He and his staff took such good care of me. I am a registered nurse, and I was very pleased every step of the way. Everything was explained to me. I highly recommend Renew Bariatrics and especially Dr. Hector Perez.”
“Dr. Perez hands down the best! He was so knowledgeable. Made sure our questions and concerns were answered. Everyone at Renew was great. From the nurses to house keepers. My husband and I have no regrets. I recommend Renew Bariatrics and definitely Dr. Perez.”
from 850+ reviews across 4 platforms
Ratings and review counts as listed on each platform. Select a platform to read reviews there.
Neither is better for everyone. The sleeve is a simpler surgery with fewer early complications and fewer vitamin problems. SADI-S leads to more weight loss and has a stronger effect on diabetes, and at Renew it’s for a BMI of 40 to 65. Our surgeons will recommend one after reviewing your health history.
In a study of 878 patients at one US center, people lost an average of 19.5 BMI points 2 years after SADI-S vs 11.3 after the sleeve.
In the short term, yes. In matched US registry patients, complications needing treatment within 30 days happened in 3.5% after SADI-S vs 1.3% after the sleeve.
No. Renew performs SADI-S, a single-connection version of the duodenal switch, with Dr. Héctor Pérez. We don’t perform the traditional BPD-DS.
Yes. SADI-S can be done as a second step after a sleeve if weight loss stalls or weight comes back. Sleeve revisions are a custom quote at Renew.
Yes, for life. SADI-S reduces how much you absorb, so you’ll need daily supplements, including vitamins A, D, E and K, and regular lab checks.
The gastric sleeve is $4,899 and SADI-S is $6,899, both all-inclusive except airfare. HSA and FSA are accepted, with financing available.
Free surgeon review
Tell us a little about you, and our team will follow up with your options and quote. No commitment.
Double board-certified surgeons with 9,000+ surgeries.
Prefer to talk? Call 24/7 (844) 736-3963
Free, no-obligation review
Form loading. Prefer to talk? Call (844) 736-3963, available 24/7.
No commitment. A coordinator will contact you.